NCAA’s NIL Myth Debunked: College Sports Popularity Soars
College sports, especially football, have always been a huge part of American culture.
But lately, the old idea that amateurism drives their popularity just doesn’t hold up.
Look at the numbers—college sports, especially football and women’s teams, are thriving even as athletes start getting paid for their efforts.
This blog post takes a closer look at what’s happening in college sports right now and how the NIL (Name, Image, Likeness) era is shaking up viewership and revenue.
The Myth of Amateurism in College Sports
Table of Contents
The NCAA spent years pushing the idea that amateurism was crucial for college sports to stay popular.
Back in 2014, the NCAA claimed in court that sticking to amateurism boosted viewership for college athletics.
But that’s just not true anymore—recent data shows fans keep tuning in, even as athletes get to profit from their own names and talents.
Supreme Court’s Verdict
Things changed in 2021 when the Supreme Court unanimously struck down the NCAA’s amateurism model.
Justice Brett Kavanaugh didn’t hold back, saying the NCAA’s business model would be illegal anywhere else.
That decision opened the door for NIL rules, letting athletes finally earn money from endorsements and other ventures.
Surging Popularity and Viewership
Even with the move away from amateurism, college sports have only gotten more popular.
The Indiana-Miami national championship game pulled in an average of 30.1 million viewers on ESPN, peaking at 33.2 million.
That’s the second-most-watched College Football Playoff national championship ever, and the biggest non-NFL sporting event since the 2016 World Series Game 7.
Women’s Sports on the Rise
It’s not just football that’s getting all the attention.
Women’s sports are seeing record-breaking popularity too.
Last year, the Women’s College World Series and NCAA volleyball tournament both set new viewership highs.
Women’s basketball, with stars like Caitlin Clark, smashed records in 2024 as well.
Fans seem to care a lot more about the quality of the games than whether the athletes are technically amateurs.
Financial Implications
The money in college sports has exploded.
Book Your Dream Vacation Today
Flights | Hotels | Vacation Rentals | Rental Cars | Experiences
Athletic departments are reporting record revenues, and coaches’ and administrators’ salaries are through the roof.
It’s wild—a college football team’s weightlifting coach can now make a seven-figure salary.
And athletes aren’t missing out either—they’re finally seeing some real money come their way.
NIL and Athlete Earnings
NIL rules give athletes the chance to cash in on their own fame and hard work.
We’re seeing big endorsement deals and new financial opportunities popping up all over.
So far, the market seems to be finding its own balance, with everyone getting a fairer share than before.
Challenges and Controversies
Of course, it’s not all smooth sailing—college sports still have their fair share of messiness and controversy.
Take the recent case of Charles Bediako, a basketball player who got a temporary restraining order to play for Alabama against Tennessee, even though he hadn’t played college ball in almost three years.
Stuff like this really makes you wonder about how eligibility rules get enforced, and whether new laws might be needed to keep things fair.
The NCAA’s Role Moving Forward
With everything changing so fast, the NCAA can’t just cling to old myths like amateurism.
It’s time for the organization to focus on rules that are actually fair and transparent, so the competitions stay legit and athletes get what they deserve.
Conclusion
The idea that amateurism is what keeps college sports alive? That’s been pretty much shattered. The Supreme Court’s decision, along with the arrival of NIL, made it clear—college sports don’t need unpaid athletes to stay popular or exciting.
Viewership numbers are through the roof. Both men’s and women’s teams are having a moment, honestly. The NCAA’s got to keep up and figure out how to balance everyone’s interests in this new landscape.
Want the full scoop? Check out the article on USA Today.